This article titled “Trump stands by ‘absolute right’ to share sensitive information with Russia” was written by Julian Borger and Sabrina Siddiqui in Washington and Amanda Holpuchin New York, for The Guardian on Tuesday 16th May 2017 20.59 UTC
Donald Trump has declared he had an “absolute right” to share information of a terrorist plot with Russia amid widespread reports he gave away highly classified information provided by Israeli intelligence.
Israel quickly declared it had “full confidence” in its intelligence-sharing agreement with the US, but there was no evidence that it had been consulted on a decision to share a tip-off – a decision the president appears to have made on the spur of the moment in a meeting last week with the Russian foreign minister, Sergei Lavrov, and the Russian ambassador to the US, Sergey Kislyak.
The intelligence Trump shared involved an Islamic State plot to use bombs hidden in laptop computers to bring down planes, according to the Washington Post, which first reported the incident. White House officials confirmed that it concerned a threat to aviation and argued it was appropriate to share such information with Russia, which has also been the victim of terrorism. They pointed to a 2015 terrorist attack on a Russian plane over Egypt.
Multiple US news organisations reported the source of the information was Israel, days before Trump is due to visit Jerusalem on Monday – a visit that has already been affected by a row with the host government over the president’s plan to visit the Western Wall without the Israeli prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu.
The Israeli embassy did not confirm or deny the reports that it was the source of the intelligence, but the ambassador, Ron Dermer, issued a statement saying: “Israel has full confidence in our intelligence-sharing relationship with the US and looks forward to deepening that relationship in the years ahead under President Trump.”
It was unclear on Tuesday whether a planned speech by Trump at the ancient fort of Masada would go ahead as planned. McMaster did not mention it in laying out an agenda for the president’s first trip abroad, which begins on Friday with a first stop in Saudi Arabia.
The US national security adviser, HR McMaster, said that the president had not been aware of the source of the information he had shared.
One of the powers of a US president is to declassify information at any moment he chooses. Trump’s Tuesday morning tweets did not specify whether the information he shared with Russia was classified.
“As president, I wanted to share with Russia (at an openly scheduled WH meeting) which I have the absolute right to do, facts pertaining to terrorism and airline flight safety,” Trump wrote. “Humanitarian reasons, plus I want Russia to greatly step up their fight against Isis and terrorism.”
Trump’s tweets contradicted flat denials issued by senior officials on Monday night, and the White House declared the report to be false. On Tuesday, McMaster offered a more calibrated response.
“What I’m saying is that the premise of the article was false – that in any way the president had a conversation that was inappropriate or that resulted in any kind of lapse in national security,” McMaster said. He argued that the real security threat came from the leaks to the press.
McMaster refused to confirm or deny whether Trump had shared classified information with Lavrov and Kislyak, repeatedly describing what Trump had revealed as being “appropriate to the conversation” and saying that the president had decided to release it “in the context of the conversation” in the Oval Office.
McMaster said that Trump had not revealed intelligence sources or methods, but he did tacitly confirm that the president had named the Syrian city in which the intelligence had been collected. “It was nothing you wouldn’t know from open source reporting,” he said. “And it had all to do with operations that are already ongoing, had been made public for months.”
He also did not dispute that the president’s counter-terrorism adviser, Tom Bossert, had called the intelligence agencies to let them know about the incident. He said he had not talked to Bossert, a key subordinate, but suggested the call could have been made “out of an abundance of caution”.
The affair has sparked an uproar over whether Trump compromised national security and made it less likely that US allies would share intelligence with Washington. It added to already intense scrutiny of the president’s ties with Moscow.
Russia’s foreign ministry spokesperson, Maria Zakharova, said on Facebook on Tuesday said the reports were “yet another fake” – and advised people not to read American newspapers.
Top politicians and intelligence officials said they were concerned the information potentially put a source at risk and was given to the US by an ally who did not give consent for it to be shared with Russia. Such a move could jeopardize existing relationships with allies familiar with Isis operations.
“The Israelis can’t avoid seeing a delicious irony. US intelligence agencies, for decades, have suspected that Israel sometimes passes information to Russia – as part of trading intelligence – and that was the CIA’s reason to be reluctant in sharing everything with the Israelis,” said Dan Raviv, a journalist and author of several books on espionage in the Middle East. “Now, America’s allies seem concerned that Trump himself might be passing sensitive intel to the Russians.”
Burkhard Lischka, a senior German lawmaker, told the Associated Press that the reports were concerning. “If it proves to be true that the American president passed on internal intelligence matters, that would be highly worrying,” Lischka said.
An official from an unnamed European country told the Associated Press that the country might stop sharing intelligence with the US in light of Trump’s disclosures to Russia.
Mitch McConnell, the Senate majority leader, lamented what he deemed to be a distraction from the Republican policy agenda.
“I think we could do with a little less drama from the White House on a lot of things,” McConnell told Bloomberg TV on Tuesday, “so that we can focus on our agenda, which is deregulation, tax reform, and repealing and replacing Obamacare.”
Other Republicans were more outspoken in their criticism of the president. Arizona senator John McCain said the reports were “deeply disturbing” and sent “a troubling signal to America’s allies and partners around the world and may impair their willingness to share intelligence with us in the future”.
McCain said: “Regrettably, the time President Trump spent sharing sensitive information with the Russians was time he did not spend focusing on Russia’s aggressive behavior, including its interference in American and European elections, its illegal invasion of Ukraine and annexation of Crimea, its other destabilizing activities across Europe, and the slaughter of innocent civilians and targeting of hospitals in Syria.”
Senator Bob Corker, the chair of the Senate foreign relations committee, warned that Trump’s White House must urgently reverse the “downward spiral” it finds itself in. “The White House has got to do something soon to bring itself under control and in order,” he said. “It’s got to happen.”
The Washington Post’s reporting cited current and former US officials. The allegations were confirmed by several other US news outlets on Monday night.
The FBI and the Senate and House intelligence committees are conducting separate investigations into Russian interference in the presidential election, which the US government has said was designed to boost Trump’s candidacy.
As president, Trump has continued to downplay the threat posed by Russia while lavishing praise on Vladimir Putin. He has dismissed the inquiries into his potential links to Russia as “fake news” – even as a number of his former campaign aides have had contacts with Russian operatives.
Trump’s former national security adviser, Michael Flynn, was forced to resign in February for secretly discussing US sanctions against Russia with Kislyak, and then misleading the vice-president, Mike Pence, about the nature of his conversations. Jeff Sessions, the attorney general and a vocal surrogate of Trump’s during the campaign, recused himself from the FBI investigation into Russia after failing to disclose his own meeting with Kislyak in his confirmation hearing before the US Senate.
Two former Trump aides, his former campaign manager Paul Manafort and informal adviser Carter Page, have had ties to Russia and pro-Kremlin operatives.
guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010